CE26 - Individus, entreprises, marchés, finance, management 2024

Inclusion of stigmatized people in the workplace: the case of lesbian employees – ODILE

Inclusion of stigmatized people in the workplace: the case of lesbian employees

The literature on inequalities based on gender and sexual orientation remains underdeveloped, with little known in particular about the experiences of lesbian women in the workplace. This project seeks to fill this gap by looking from different angles at the characteristics of lesbian employees and the way in which their gender and sexual orientation jointly influence their experiences at work.

Main issues raised and general objectives

Inclusion has become a vital issue for companies and organisations (Cottrill et al., 2014) and has been proposed to complement the notion of diversity, emphasizing the importance of authenticity at work. Practices of inclusion in organizations are critical in the case of invisible social identities (Ragins et al., 2007). Indeed, individuals with an invisible social identity face conflicting demands related to hiding or disclosing their invisible identity. Hiding their identity requires strong efforts and a mental burden and prevents them from being authentic at work, which can result in isolation and psychological suffering (Clair et al., 2005; Herek, 1996). Inclusion is, therefore, essential for allowing them to disclose their invisible identity without risking discrimination and stigmatization. This is the case, for example, for homosexual people, for whom it has been shown that inclusion policies are central to enabling people who wish to disclose their identity to do so without risk (Falcoz & Bécuwe, 2009; Maji et al., 2023). LG (lesbian and gay) people are victims of several forms of violence at work: discrimination (in access to employment, responsibilities, for example), stigmatization, humiliation, and sexual violence, among others (Coron & Dorion, forthcoming; Zurbrügg & Miner, 2016). Women, regardless of their sexual orientation, are also victims of discrimination and violence in the workplace (Coron, 2023; Laufer, 2014). This research project lies at the intersection of these two fields. It aims to describe and understand the experiences of lesbian employees at work and how organizations can become more inclusive for these women (acronym ODILE: Organization - Diversity - Inclusion - LEsbians). Our overall research hypothesis, based on the intersectional paradigm and on the fact that discrimination based on sexual orientation is deeply entrenched with gender norms (Beaubatie et al., 2023), is that lesbian women, both as women and as homosexuals, have specific experiences at work. The project, therefore, has several aims: - On an empirical level, to understand, from an intersectional approach, the specific experiences (negative or positive) of lesbian employees and how they differ from the ones of heterosexual female employees or gay male employees (but also heterosexual male employees); - On a theoretical level, to enrich the literature on the inclusion of LG people and the literature on gender by crossing these two themes; - On a managerial level, to offer companies recommendations for implementing policies and practices to ensure greater inclusion of lesbian employees.

The project is based on 3 work packages.

WP1 is a qualitative survey based on semi-structured interviews with lesbian employees (50), managers (10) and diversity officers (10). This WP aims to explore the themes identified in previous literature (coming-out, career, identity, social issues and experiences, discrimination and violence, role of networks of LG employees, and company policies aimed at the inclusion of LG people), but focusing on lesbian employees working in France.

WP2 is an online qualitative survey designed to gather accounts of female employees' experiences of work online via an observatory. Questions will be published periodically on this observatory, making it possible to collect written testimonies.

WP3 concerns the collection and analysis of data on a representative sample of French employees, via the administration of a questionnaire containing questions on gender, sexual orientation and work-related issues. This WP3 therefore has several objectives: firstly, to remedy the lack of data on sexual orientation in national statistical surveys, which currently prevents the production of robust results on occupational inequalities based on gender and sexual orientation; to compare and measure the occupational situation (objective and subjective) of lesbian women, heterosexual women, gay men and heterosexual men; and finally, to produce reliable figures on occupational inequalities based on gender and sexual orientation.

 

The results will be provided at the end of the project.

Homosexual people (lesbians and gays) are victims of several forms of violence at work: discrimination (in access to employment, responsibilities, for example), stigmatization, humiliation, and sexual violence, among others (Zurbrügg & Miner, 2016). Women, whatever their sexual orientation, are also victims of discrimination and violence in the workplace (Laufer, 2014). This research project lies at the intersection of these two fields, and aims to describe and understand the work experience of lesbian employees, and how work organizations can become more inclusive for these women (acronym ODILE: Organization - Diversity - Inclusion - LEsbians). In doing so, it integrates a "gender approach" into the understanding of discrimination and violence experienced by homosexual people at work. The project is based on three studies: a qualitative exploratory study based on interviews, a netnography, and a quantitative study based on a questionnaire in order to create and analyze a representative database of French employees. It aims to enrich the literature on gender and the literature on the inclusion of homosexual people by crossing them and showing the specificity of lesbian employees' experiences at work. This enrichment will also shed light on the notion of inclusion, which is increasingly used (but also criticized) in academic literature.

Project coordination

Clotilde Coron (Université Paris-Saclay)

The author of this summary is the project coordinator, who is responsible for the content of this summary. The ANR declines any responsibility as for its contents.

Partnership

UPSaclay-RITM Université Paris-Saclay

Help of the ANR 209,320 euros
Beginning and duration of the scientific project: December 2024 - 24 Months

Useful links

Explorez notre base de projets financés

 

 

ANR makes available its datasets on funded projects, click here to find more.

Sign up for the latest news:
Subscribe to our newsletter