CE02 - Terre vivante 2020

Influence of effective population size on animal genome architecture – NeGA

Influence of effective population size on animal genome architecture

Eukaryotes have complex genomes whose origin remains debated. Lynch (2003) proposes a non-adaptive explanation: genomic complexity would result from a balance between the emergence of slightly deleterious variants and their fixation. The effective population size (Ne) would be the key factor regulating this balance. This hypothesis, although widely cited, remains poorly tested empirically.

In the NeGA project, we exploit genomic data from closely related species that contrast in Ne, across different animal groups. We assess the influence of Ne on genome size and on the dynamics of transposable elements. We test the influence of Ne on gene structure and transcriptional complexity. In parallel, we use simulation and modelling tools to understand the conditions under which Lynch's theory fails, with the ultimate goal of redefining the boundaries of this theory.

The project is based on the study of biological groups where the impact of multiple population size variations between species is investigated. One of these groups consists of in silico organisms.

In addition to this approach focused on specific groups of interest, the project rapidly integrated a large-scale approach (e.g. metazoans) to study at this scale the relationship between population size and genome architecture. This large-scale approach combines both macroevolutionary and microevolutionary analyses.

The genomic traits studied in the project are diverse: polymorphism, protein evolution rates, splicing rates, base composition, size and diversity of the repeatome, etc. For example, as part of Alba Marino's PhD thesis, we assembled a dataset of 773 animal genomes. Transposable elements were annotated for 672 species.

The resources mobilised are first and foremost human: hiring and hosting of young researchers (4 PhD students) and one engineer. Finally, significant resources have been devoted to the acquisition of new genomic data.

1. Micro and macroevolutionary effects of Ne (M. Bastian's PhD thesis)

 

The objective was to test the nearly neutral theory on the evolution of coding sequences in 144 placental mammals, integrating inter-species divergence and intra-species polymorphism for ~8,000 orthologous genes (heterozygosity and dN/dS). The results confirm all predictions of the nearly neutral theory, for the first time at both micro and macroevolutionary scales (Bastian et al., 2026).

 

2. Ne, repeated elements and genome size (A. Marino's PhD thesis)

 

The objective was to test the relationship between Ne, genome size and the dynamics of repeated elements (~800 species and annotation of transposable elements). The results show no link between Ne and genome size, nor with transposable element activity. Ne is not a global evolutionary factor influencing genome size in animals (Marino et al., 2025).

 

3. Ne, gene composition and expression (F. Bénitière's PhD thesis)

 

The objective was to evaluate the extent to which the drift barrier influences the evolution of gene base composition (223 metazoan species with measurement of translational selection) as well as the complexity of produced isoforms (53 metazoan species, GTDrift database, Bénitière et al., 2024a). The results show strong variation in alternative splicing rates across animals, with an inverse correlation between Ne and alternative splicing rate: species with low Ne exhibit higher alternative splicing (Bénitière et al., 2024b). We also observe a weak signal of translational selection in most metazoans, with stronger selection in species with large Ne, but absent in some despite high Ne. Selection on synonymous codons may be modulated by other factors such as growth rate (Bénitière et al., 2025).

 

4. Ne and genomic robustness (J. Luiselli's PhD thesis)

 

Alongside comparative studies, a modelling approach was initiated to test in silico the effect of Ne on genome structure. Simulations of circular haploid genomes (bacterial model) and a generalisation to eukaryotic genomes (diploid, linear, sexual) were used. The results show that with the "bacterial" model, chromosomal rearrangements promote long-term adaptation and stabilisation of genome size (Banse et al., 2024). The pressure on genome size is modulated by mutation rate and population size (Luiselli et al., 2024). This result is confirmed by a mathematical model: these two parameters determine an equilibrium proportion of non-coding genome (Luiselli et al., 2025). We generalised these results to diploid sexually reproducing organisms with meiotic recombination: eukaryotic-type genomes respond to changes in mutation rate and Ne in an analogous manner.

Overall, these findings highlight a paradox. While the micro-evolutionary effects of Ne are confirmed by both empirical and theoretical data, only some of the patterns predicted by Lynch's theory are recovered at large scales. The relationship between Ne and genome size is clear in certain groups but is lost globally. For other genomic traits, a relationship is found (e.g. alternative splicing rate), but remains weak for others (e.g. translational selection).

 

These findings open perspectives on the regulation of transposable element (TE) activity and on why certain lineages undergo dramatic genome size increases. Selection may only act when genomes are actively expanding: active TEs could be more efficiently counter-selected in large populations, whereas inactive TEs may no longer affect fitness, leaving non-coding DNA without strong selective pressure for reduction. Counter-selection of active TEs can thus limit genome expansion in some populations.

 

Another perspective is the direct reuse of project-generated data. For instance, the ecological genomics model in subterranean environments will be applied to study the impact of phenotypic trait loss and trophic changes on symbiotic interactions.

 

The theoretical approaches developed during the project also offer rich prospects for exploring co-evolution between mutation rates and patterns, recombination landscapes, and genome size and complexity.

 

Finally, work conducted at the micro-macro interface serves as a starting point for new research projects centred on (i) building integrated micro-macro data matrices across all orthologous genes; and (ii) integrative modelling of short- and long-term Ne evolution across the phylogeny and its impact on coding sequence evolution.

Submission summary

Eukaryotic organisms exhibit strikingly complex gene and genome architectures whose origin remains largely debated. In 2003, Michael Lynch proposed that this complexity emerged thanks to non-adaptive forces. Under this hypothesis, many genomic traits would be controlled by the balance between the emergence of slightly deleterious variants and their fixation rate, which ultimately depends on the effective population size (Ne). Although appealing because it is based on universal principles of population genetics, Lynch's theory has rarely been tested empirically. Here, we will compare the genome architecture of closely related species with contrasted Ne in five different groups of animals. We will first evaluate the influence of Ne on the evolution of genome size and on the dynamics of transposable elements. Then, we will test if Ne has an influence on the gene structure (number and size of introns) and transcription complexity (number and frequency of alternative transcripts). In parallel, we will use modeling and simulations to understand the reasons for a possible lack of applicability and to ultimately redefine or refine the contours of Lynch’s theory.

Project coordination

Tristan Lefébure (LABORATOIRE D'ECOLOGIE DES HYDROSYSTEMES NATURELS ANTHROPISES)

The author of this summary is the project coordinator, who is responsible for the content of this summary. The ANR declines any responsibility as for its contents.

Partnership

LEHNA LABORATOIRE D'ECOLOGIE DES HYDROSYSTEMES NATURELS ANTHROPISES
Inria Grenoble Rhône-Alpes Centre de Recherche Inria Grenoble - Rhône-Alpes
ISEM Institut des Sciences de l'Evolution de Montpellier
LBBE BIOMÉTRIE ET BIOLOGIE EVOLUTIVE

Help of the ANR 571,719 euros
Beginning and duration of the scientific project: February 2021 - 48 Months

Useful links

Explorez notre base de projets financés

 

 

ANR makes available its datasets on funded projects, click here to find more.

Sign up for the latest news:
Subscribe to our newsletter